Formula change for Instone Pudding

[wedgylx]

The manager at a GNC told me that Instone changed thier formula and they have been restocking the new formular for 2 weeks. He said it tastes alot worse than it used to. Is this bogus?

[ghostwheel]

It was a very popular product why would they change it?

Doesn't make sense. I am hesitant to beleive GNC people.

[max von]

i hope not ,im glad I got one case left then

max von

[wedgylx]

i asked another worker (like all of you i take thier words word a grain of salt) and she said they come in larger containers now but she didnt think the forumular changed at all, and either they add more water now or the first containers didnt have the full 20g of protein?

[ghostwheel]

Did you hear anything else on this? I am still waiting for my DA order of Instone pudding to arrive here in Hawaii.


Forgot to order the Oh Yeah bars this time. Drat!

[wedgylx]

Did you hear anything else on this? I am still waiting for my DA order of Instone pudding to arrive here in Hawaii.


Forgot to order the Oh Yeah bars this time. Drat!

havent heard anything new. I guess who cares. I had the new, larger can and tasted the same to me

[ghostwheel]

If it tasted the same, that is what I wanted to know.

I don't know if DA shipped the bigger or smaller can type.

What were the different sizes?

[wedgylx]

If it tasted the same, that is what I wanted to know.

I don't know if DA shipped the bigger or smaller can type.

What were the different sizes?

both had 20g protein, im assuming its a water difference

[ghostwheel]

Yes but what was the net weight?

That way I can tell if I get the big or small can.

Thanx.

[wedgylx]

Yes but what was the net weight?

That way I can tell if I get the big or small can.

Thanx.

not sure, sorry. I'll see what i can dig up later, after finals

[ghostwheel]

DOn't want to make you go digging through trash bins to fins an old can of pudding to check the net weight.

I can't even REMEMBER my last final at UCLA.

Seems like forever ago.

[ghostwheel]

My cans of pudding have arrived. I noticed that the chocolate seems to get solid when chilled while the vanilla is more watery.

I think I am going to vote for chocolate, but I will have a few more cans to make up mind which flavor tastes best.

Of course we can always just add whey powder protein to jello pudding mix and make our own jello. :)

[max von]

My cans of pudding have arrived. I noticed that the chocolate seems to get solid when chilled while the vanilla is more watery.

I think I am going to vote for chocolate, but I will have a few more cans to make up mind which flavor tastes best.

Of course we can always just add whey powder protein to jello pudding mix and make our own jello. :)

prob much cheaper that way to

max von

[wedgylx]

doesnt pudding need to be boiled though? I'm assuming boiling the whey wastes alot of it

[dinoiii]

[dinoiii]

Net Weight

Old Formula: 5.82 oz. (165g)

New Formula: 6.4 oz. (182g)


* Btw - the label inaccuracy had NOTHING to do with water and it is good to see the company making ammends.

[wedgylx]

Net Weight

Old Formula: 5.82 oz. (165g)

New Formula: 6.4 oz. (182g)


* Btw - the label inaccuracy had NOTHING to do with water and it is good to see the company making ammends.

so there wasnt the full 20g of protein in the old ones is what you're saying?

[ghostwheel]

doesnt pudding need to be boiled though? I'm assuming boiling the whey wastes alot of it

Can't you mix in the whey just after boiling the pudding mix???

BTW from the net weights posted I got the new version.

[wedgylx]

doesnt pudding need to be boiled though? I'm assuming boiling the whey wastes alot of it

Can't you mix in the whey just after boiling the pudding mix???

BTW from the net weights posted I got the new version.

lol yeah i guess you could. Try it and let me know how it comes out.

[max von]

doesnt pudding need to be boiled though? I'm assuming boiling the whey wastes alot of it

thats a good point cause you do have to do that or microwave it so it would prob waste lot of it away

max von

[dinoiii]

Agreed on the macronutrient breakdown. Although one could argue that the protein sources used in it still make it < 20 grams of "quality."

You can be the judge. I suppose it is better than eating some of the other things on the market.

[wedgylx]

Agreed on the macronutrient breakdown. Although one could argue that the protein sources used in it still make it < 20 grams of "quality."

You can be the judge. I suppose it is better than eating some of the other things on the market.

you mean because of the soy?

[dinoiii]

HPLC has shown that initial batches should have listed soy before caseinate.